weseek__growi/apps/app/test/integration/models/v5.page.test.js

import { PageGrant, GroupType } from '@growi/core';
import mongoose from 'mongoose';

import { ExternalGroupProviderType } from '../../../src/features/external-user-group/interfaces/external-user-group';
import ExternalUserGroup from '../../../src/features/external-user-group/server/models/external-user-group';
import ExternalUserGroupRelation from '../../../src/features/external-user-group/server/models/external-user-group-relation';
import UserGroup from '../../../src/server/models/user-group';
import UserGroupRelation from '../../../src/server/models/user-group-relation';
import { getInstance } from '../setup-crowi';

describe('Page', () => {
  let crowi;
  let pageGrantService;
  let pageService;

  let Page;
  let Revision;
  let User;
  let PageTagRelation;
  let Bookmark;
  let Comment;
  let ShareLink;
  let PageRedirect;
  let xssSpy;

  let rootPage;
  let dummyUser1;
  let pModelUser1;
  let pModelUser2;
  let pModelUser3;
  let userGroupIdPModelIsolate;
  let userGroupIdPModelA;
  let userGroupIdPModelB;
  let userGroupIdPModelC;
  let externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate;
  let externalUserGroupIdPModelA;
  let externalUserGroupIdPModelB;
  let externalUserGroupIdPModelC;

  // To test updatePage overwriting descendants (prefix `upod`)
  let upodUserA;
  let upodUserB;
  let upodUserC;
  let upodGroupAB;
  let upodGroupA;
  let upodGroupAIsolated;
  let upodGroupB;
  let upodGroupC;
  const upodUserGroupIdA = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodUserGroupIdAIsolated = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodUserGroupIdB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodUserGroupIdC = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodUserGroupIdAB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodExternalUserGroupIdA = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodExternalUserGroupIdAIsolated = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodExternalUserGroupIdB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodExternalUserGroupIdC = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodExternalUserGroupIdAB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdgAB1 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdPublic2 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdPublic3 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdPublic4 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdPublic5 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
  const upodPageIdPublic6 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();

  const updatePage = async(page, newRevisionBody, oldRevisionBody, user, options = {}) => {
    const mockedUpdatePageSubOperation = jest.spyOn(pageService, 'updatePageSubOperation').mockReturnValue(null);

    const savedPage = await pageService.updatePage(page, newRevisionBody, oldRevisionBody, user, options);

    const argsForUpdatePageSubOperation = mockedUpdatePageSubOperation.mock.calls[0];

    mockedUpdatePageSubOperation.mockRestore();

    await pageService.updatePageSubOperation(...argsForUpdatePageSubOperation);

    return savedPage;
  };

  const createDocumentsToTestUpdatePageOverwritingDescendants = async() => {
    // Users
    await User.insertMany([
      { name: 'upodUserA', username: 'upodUserA', email: 'upoduserA@example.com' },
      { name: 'upodUserB', username: 'upodUserB', email: 'upoduserB@example.com' },
      { name: 'upodUserC', username: 'upodUserC', email: 'upodUserC@example.com' },
    ]);

    upodUserA = await User.findOne({ username: 'upodUserA' });
    upodUserB = await User.findOne({ username: 'upodUserB' });
    upodUserC = await User.findOne({ username: 'upodUserC' });

    await UserGroup.insertMany([
      {
        _id: upodUserGroupIdAB,
        name: 'upodGroupAB',
        parent: null,
      },
      {
        _id: upodUserGroupIdA,
        name: 'upodGroupA',
        parent: upodUserGroupIdAB,
      },
      {
        _id: upodUserGroupIdAIsolated,
        name: 'upodGroupAIsolated',
        parent: null,
      },
      {
        _id: upodUserGroupIdB,
        name: 'upodGroupB',
        parent: upodUserGroupIdAB,
      },
      {
        _id: upodUserGroupIdC,
        name: 'upodGroupC',
        parent: null,
      },
    ]);

    upodGroupAB = await UserGroup.findOne({ name: 'upodGroupAB' });
    upodGroupA = await UserGroup.findOne({ name: 'upodGroupA' });
    upodGroupAIsolated = await UserGroup.findOne({ name: 'upodGroupAIsolated' });
    upodGroupB = await UserGroup.findOne({ name: 'upodGroupB' });
    upodGroupC = await UserGroup.findOne({ name: 'upodGroupC' });

    // UserGroupRelations
    await UserGroupRelation.insertMany([
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdAB,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdAB,
        relatedUser: upodUserB._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdA,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdAIsolated,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdB,
        relatedUser: upodUserB._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodUserGroupIdC,
        relatedUser: upodUserC._id,
      },
    ]);

    // Insert ExternalUserGroups with the same group structure as UserGroups
    // Use to test
    //   - ExternalUserGroup
    //   - Case of multiple grantedGroups for Page
    await ExternalUserGroup.insertMany([
      {
        _id: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB,
        name: 'upodExternalGroupAB',
        parent: null,
        externalId: 'upodExternalGroupAB',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: upodExternalUserGroupIdA,
        name: 'upodExternalGroupA',
        parent: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB,
        externalId: 'upodExternalGroupA',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: upodExternalUserGroupIdAIsolated,
        name: 'upodExternalGroupAIsolated',
        parent: null,
        externalId: 'upodExternalGroupAIsolated',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: upodExternalUserGroupIdB,
        name: 'upodExternalGroupB',
        parent: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB,
        externalId: 'upodExternalGroupB',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: upodExternalUserGroupIdC,
        name: 'upodExternalGroupC',
        parent: null,
        externalId: 'upodExternalGroupC',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
    ]);

    // ExternalUserGroupRelations
    await ExternalUserGroupRelation.insertMany([
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB,
        relatedUser: upodUserB._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdA,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdAIsolated,
        relatedUser: upodUserA._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdB,
        relatedUser: upodUserB._id,
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: upodExternalUserGroupIdC,
        relatedUser: upodUserC._id,
      },
    ]);

    // Pages
    await Page.insertMany([
      // case 1
      {
        _id: upodPageIdgAB1,
        path: '/gAB_upod_1', // to GRANT_PUBLIC
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/gAB_upod_1/gB_upod_1',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserB,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserB,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdgAB1,
      },
      {
        path: '/gAB_upod_1/onlyB_upod_1',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: upodUserB,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserB,
        grantedUsers: [upodUserB._id],
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: upodPageIdgAB1,
      },
      // case 2
      {
        _id: upodPageIdPublic2,
        path: '/public_upod_2', // to Anything
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_2/gA_upod_2',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic2,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_2/gAIsolated_upod_2',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAIsolated, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAIsolated, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic2,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_2/onlyA_upod_2',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: [upodUserA._id],
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: upodPageIdPublic2,
      },
      // case 3
      {
        _id: upodPageIdPublic3,
        path: '/public_upod_3', // to GRANT_USER_GROUP with upodGroupAB
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_3/gAB_upod_3',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic3,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_3/gB_upod_3',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserB,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserB,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic3,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_3/onlyB_upod_3',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: upodUserB,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserB,
        grantedUsers: [upodUserB._id],
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: upodPageIdPublic3,
      },
      // case 4
      {
        _id: upodPageIdPublic4,
        path: '/public_upod_4', // to GRANT_USER_GROUP with upodGroupAB
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_4/gA_upod_4',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic4,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_4/gC_upod_4',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserC,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserC,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdC, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdC, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic4,
      },
      // case 5
      {
        _id: upodPageIdPublic5,
        path: '/public_upod_5', // to GRANT_USER_GROUP with upodGroupAB
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_5/gA_upod_5',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        parent: upodPageIdPublic5,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_5/onlyC_upod_5',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: upodUserC,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserC,
        grantedUsers: [upodUserC._id],
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: upodPageIdPublic5,
      },
      // case 6
      {
        _id: upodPageIdPublic6,
        path: '/public_upod_6', // to GRANT_USER_GROUP with upodGroupAB
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: upodUserA,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserA,
        grantedUsers: null,
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: rootPage._id,
      },
      {
        path: '/public_upod_6/onlyC_upod_6',
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: upodUserC,
        lastUpdateUser: upodUserC,
        grantedUsers: [upodUserC._id],
        grantedGroups: null,
        parent: upodPageIdPublic6,
      },
    ]);
  };

  // normalize for result comparison
  const normalizeGrantedGroups = (grantedGroups) => {
    return grantedGroups.map((group) => {
      const itemId = typeof group.item === 'string' ? group.item : group.item._id;
      return { item: itemId, type: group.type };
    });
  };

  beforeAll(async() => {
    crowi = await getInstance();
    pageGrantService = crowi.pageGrantService;
    pageService = crowi.pageService;

    await crowi.configManager.updateConfigsInTheSameNamespace('crowi', { 'app:isV5Compatible': true });

    jest.restoreAllMocks();
    User = mongoose.model('User');
    Page = mongoose.model('Page');
    Revision = mongoose.model('Revision');
    PageTagRelation = mongoose.model('PageTagRelation');
    Bookmark = mongoose.model('Bookmark');
    Comment = mongoose.model('Comment');
    ShareLink = mongoose.model('ShareLink');
    PageRedirect = mongoose.model('PageRedirect');

    dummyUser1 = await User.findOne({ username: 'v5DummyUser1' });

    rootPage = await Page.findOne({ path: '/' });

    const pModelUserId1 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pModelUserId2 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pModelUserId3 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    await User.insertMany([
      {
        _id: pModelUserId1,
        name: 'pmodelUser1',
        username: 'pmodelUser1',
        email: 'pmodelUser1@example.com',
      },
      {
        _id: pModelUserId2,
        name: 'pmodelUser2',
        username: 'pmodelUser2',
        email: 'pmodelUser2@example.com',
      },
      {
        _id: pModelUserId3,
        name: 'pModelUser3',
        username: 'pModelUser3',
        email: 'pModelUser3@example.com',
      },
    ]);
    pModelUser1 = await User.findOne({ _id: pModelUserId1 });
    pModelUser2 = await User.findOne({ _id: pModelUserId2 });
    pModelUser3 = await User.findOne({ _id: pModelUserId3 });


    userGroupIdPModelIsolate = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    userGroupIdPModelA = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    userGroupIdPModelB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    userGroupIdPModelC = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    await UserGroup.insertMany([
      {
        _id: userGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        name: 'pModel_groupIsolate',
      },
      {
        _id: userGroupIdPModelA,
        name: 'pModel_groupA',
      },
      {
        _id: userGroupIdPModelB,
        name: 'pModel_groupB',
        parent: userGroupIdPModelA,
      },
      {
        _id: userGroupIdPModelC,
        name: 'pModel_groupC',
        parent: userGroupIdPModelB,
      },
    ]);

    await UserGroupRelation.insertMany([
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId1,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId1,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelB,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelB,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: userGroupIdPModelC,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
    ]);

    // Insert ExternalUserGroups with the same group structure as UserGroups
    // Use to test
    //   - ExternalUserGroup
    //   - Case of multiple grantedGroups for Page
    externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    externalUserGroupIdPModelA = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    externalUserGroupIdPModelB = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    externalUserGroupIdPModelC = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    await ExternalUserGroup.insertMany([
      {
        _id: externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        name: 'pModel_externalGroupIsolate',
        externalId: 'pModel_externalGroupIsolate',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: externalUserGroupIdPModelA,
        name: 'pModel_externalGroupA',
        externalId: 'pModel_externalGroupA',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: externalUserGroupIdPModelB,
        name: 'pModel_externalGroupB',
        parent: externalUserGroupIdPModelA,
        externalId: 'pModel_externalGroupB',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
      {
        _id: externalUserGroupIdPModelC,
        name: 'pModel_externalGroupC',
        parent: externalUserGroupIdPModelB,
        externalId: 'pModel_externalGroupC',
        provider: ExternalGroupProviderType.ldap,
      },
    ]);

    await ExternalUserGroupRelation.insertMany([
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId1,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId1,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelA,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelB,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId2,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelB,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
      {
        relatedGroup: externalUserGroupIdPModelC,
        relatedUser: pModelUserId3,
        createdAt: new Date(),
      },
    ]);

    /**
     * update
     * mup_ => model update
     * emp => empty => page with isEmpty: true
     * pub => public => GRANT_PUBLIC
     * awl => Anyone with the link => GRANT_RESTRICTED
     */
    const pageIdUpd1 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd2 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd3 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd4 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd5 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd6 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd7 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd8 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd9 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd10 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd11 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd12 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd13 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd14 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd15 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd16 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd17 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd18 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();
    const pageIdUpd19 = new mongoose.Types.ObjectId();

    await Page.insertMany([
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd1,
        path: '/mup13_top/mup1_emp',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        parent: pageIdUpd8._id,
        isEmpty: true,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd2,
        path: '/mup13_top/mup1_emp/mup2_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        parent: pageIdUpd1._id,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd3,
        path: '/mup14_top/mup6_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        parent: pageIdUpd9,
        isEmpty: false,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup14_top/mup6_pub/mup7_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        parent: pageIdUpd3,
        isEmpty: false,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd4,
        path: '/mup15_top/mup8_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        parent: pageIdUpd10._id,
        isEmpty: false,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd5,
        path: '/mup16_top/mup9_pub/mup10_pub/mup11_awl',
        grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd6,
        path: '/mup17_top/mup12_emp',
        isEmpty: true,
        parent: pageIdUpd12._id,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd7,
        path: '/mup17_top/mup12_emp',
        grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup17_top/mup12_emp/mup18_pub',
        isEmpty: false,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        parent: pageIdUpd6._id,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd8,
        path: '/mup13_top',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 2,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd9,
        path: '/mup14_top',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 2,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd10,
        path: '/mup15_top',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd11,
        path: '/mup16_top',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd12,
        path: '/mup17_top',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup19',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup20',
        grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup21',
        grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED,
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd13,
        path: '/mup22',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: pModelUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup22/mup23',
        grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd13,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd14,
        path: '/mup24_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup24_pub/mup25_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd14,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup26_awl',
        grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED,
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd15,
        path: '/mup27_pub',
        grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup27_pub/mup28_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd15,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId1],
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd16,
        path: '/mup29_A',
        grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup29_A/mup30_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId1],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd16,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd17,
        path: '/mup31_A',
        grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup31_A/mup32_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId1],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd17,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd18,
        path: '/mup33_C',
        grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantedGroups: [
          { item: userGroupIdPModelC, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelC, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        creator: pModelUserId3,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId3,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup33_C/mup34_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId3],
        creator: pModelUserId3,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId3,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd18,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        _id: pageIdUpd19,
        path: '/mup35_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId1],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage,
        descendantCount: 1,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup35_owner/mup36_owner',
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [pModelUserId1],
        creator: pModelUserId1,
        lastUpdateUser: pModelUserId1,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: pageIdUpd19,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
      {
        path: '/mup40', // used this number to resolve conflict
        grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER,
        grantedUsers: [dummyUser1._id],
        creator: dummyUser1,
        lastUpdateUser: dummyUser1._id,
        isEmpty: false,
        parent: rootPage._id,
        descendantCount: 0,
      },
    ]);

    await createDocumentsToTestUpdatePageOverwritingDescendants();
  });

  describe('update', () => {
    describe('Changing grant from PUBLIC to RESTRICTED of', () => {
      test('an only-child page will delete its empty parent page', async() => {
        const pathT = '/mup13_top';
        const path1 = '/mup13_top/mup1_emp';
        const path2 = '/mup13_top/mup1_emp/mup2_pub';
        const pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT, descendantCount: 2 });
        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, isEmpty: true });
        const page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        expect(pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page2).toBeTruthy();

        const options = { grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED, grantUserGroupIds: null };
        await updatePage(page2, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, options);

        const _pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1 });
        const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
        expect(_pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page1).toBeNull();
        expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_pageT.descendantCount).toBe(1);
      });
      test('a page that has children will create an empty page with the same path and it becomes a new parent', async() => {
        const pathT = '/mup14_top';
        const path1 = '/mup14_top/mup6_pub';
        const path2 = '/mup14_top/mup6_pub/mup7_pub';
        const top = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT, descendantCount: 2 });
        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        const page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        expect(top).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page2).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(page1, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });

        const _top = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
        const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2 });
        const _pageN = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_pageN).toBeTruthy();

        expect(_page1.parent).toBeNull();
        expect(_page2.parent).toStrictEqual(_pageN._id);
        expect(_pageN.parent).toStrictEqual(top._id);
        expect(_pageN.isEmpty).toBe(true);
        expect(_pageN.descendantCount).toBe(1);
        expect(_top.descendantCount).toBe(1);
      });
      test('of a leaf page will NOT have an empty page with the same path', async() => {
        const pathT = '/mup15_top';
        const path1 = '/mup15_top/mup8_pub';
        const pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT, descendantCount: 1 });
        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        const count = await Page.count({ path: path1 });
        expect(pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(count).toBe(1);

        await updatePage(page1, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });

        const _pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
        const _pageNotExist = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, isEmpty: true });
        expect(_pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_pageNotExist).toBeNull();
        expect(_pageT.descendantCount).toBe(0);
      });
    });

    describe('Changing grant to GRANT_RESTRICTED', () => {
      test('successfully change to GRANT_RESTRICTED from GRANT_OWNER', async() => {
        const path = '/mup40';
        const _page = await Page.findOne({ path, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [dummyUser1._id] });
        expect(_page).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(_page, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });

        const page = await Page.findOne({ path });
        expect(page).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED);
        expect(page.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([]);
      });
    });

    describe('Changing grant from RESTRICTED to PUBLIC of', () => {
      test('a page will create ancestors if they do not exist', async() => {
        const pathT = '/mup16_top';
        const path1 = '/mup16_top/mup9_pub';
        const path2 = '/mup16_top/mup9_pub/mup10_pub';
        const path3 = '/mup16_top/mup9_pub/mup10_pub/mup11_awl';
        const top = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1 });
        const page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2 });
        const page3 = await Page.findOne({ path: path3, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
        expect(top).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page3).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1).toBeNull();
        expect(page2).toBeNull();

        await updatePage(page3, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });

        const _pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, isEmpty: true });
        const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, isEmpty: true });
        const _page3 = await Page.findOne({ path: path3, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page3).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page1.parent).toStrictEqual(top._id);
        expect(_page2.parent).toStrictEqual(_page1._id);
        expect(_page3.parent).toStrictEqual(_page2._id);
        expect(_pageT.descendantCount).toBe(1);
      });
      test('a page will replace an empty page with the same path if any', async() => {
        const pathT = '/mup17_top';
        const path1 = '/mup17_top/mup12_emp';
        const path2 = '/mup17_top/mup12_emp/mup18_pub';
        const pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT, descendantCount: 1 });
        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, isEmpty: true });
        const page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED, isEmpty: false });
        const page3 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2 });
        expect(pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page2).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page3).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(page2, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });

        const _pageT = await Page.findOne({ path: pathT });
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, isEmpty: true }); // should be replaced
        const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        const _page3 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2 });
        expect(_pageT).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page1).toBeNull();
        expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page3).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_PUBLIC);
        expect(_page2.parent).toStrictEqual(_pageT._id);
        expect(_page3.parent).toStrictEqual(_page2._id);
        expect(_pageT.descendantCount).toBe(2);
      });
    });

    describe('Changing grant to GRANT_OWNER(onlyme)', () => {
      test('successfully change to GRANT_OWNER from GRANT_PUBLIC', async() => {
        const path = '/mup19';
        const _page = await Page.findOne({ path, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        expect(_page).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(_page, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER });

        const page = await Page.findOne({ path });
        expect(page.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER);
        expect(page.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([dummyUser1._id]);

      });
      test('successfully change to GRANT_OWNER from GRANT_USER_GROUP', async() => {
        const path = '/mup20';
        const _page = await Page.findOne({ path, grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantedGroups: { $elemMatch: { item: userGroupIdPModelA } } });
        expect(_page).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(_page, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', pModelUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER });

        const page = await Page.findOne({ path });
        expect(page.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER);
        expect(page.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([pModelUser1._id]);
        expect(page.grantedGroups.length).toBe(0);
      });
      test('successfully change to GRANT_OWNER from GRANT_RESTRICTED', async() => {
        const path = '/mup21';
        const _page = await Page.findOne({ path, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
        expect(_page).toBeTruthy();

        await updatePage(_page, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER });

        const page = await Page.findOne({ path });
        expect(page.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER);
        expect(page.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([dummyUser1._id]);
      });
      test('Failed to change to GRANT_OWNER if one of the ancestors is GRANT_USER_GROUP page', async() => {
        const path1 = '/mup22';
        const path2 = '/mup22/mup23';
        const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC });
        const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantedGroups: { $elemMatch: { item: userGroupIdPModelA } } });
        expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

        await expect(updatePage(_page1, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', dummyUser1, { grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER }))
          .rejects.toThrow(new Error('The selected grant or grantedGroup is not assignable to this page.'));

        const page1 = await Page.findOne({ path1 });
        expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
        expect(page1.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_PUBLIC);
        expect(page1.grantedUsers).not.toStrictEqual([dummyUser1._id]);
      });
    });
    describe('Changing grant to GRANT_USER_GROUP', () => {
      describe('update grant of a page under a page with GRANT_PUBLIC', () => {
        test('successfully change to GRANT_USER_GROUP from GRANT_PUBLIC if parent page is GRANT_PUBLIC', async() => {
          // path
          const path1 = '/mup24_pub';
          const path2 = '/mup24_pub/mup25_pub';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC }); // out of update scope
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC, parent: _page1._id }); // update target
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          const newGrantedGroups = [
            { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
            { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
          ];

          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: newGrantedGroups,
          };
          const updatedPage = await updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser1, options); // from GRANT_PUBLIC to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelA)

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage._id).toStrictEqual(page2._id);

          // check page2 grant and group
          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
          expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(page2.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);
        });

        test('successfully change to GRANT_USER_GROUP from GRANT_RESTRICTED if parent page is GRANT_PUBLIC', async() => {
          // path
          const _path1 = '/mup26_awl';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: _path1, grant: Page.GRANT_RESTRICTED });
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();

          const newGrantedGroups = [
            { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
            { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
          ];

          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: newGrantedGroups,
          };
          const updatedPage = await updatePage(_page1, 'new', 'old', pModelUser1, options); // from GRANT_RESTRICTED to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelA)

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage._id).toStrictEqual(page1._id);

          // updated page
          expect(page1.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
          expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(page1.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);

          // parent's grant check
          const parent = await Page.findById(page1.parent);
          expect(parent.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_PUBLIC);

        });

        test('successfully change to GRANT_USER_GROUP from GRANT_OWNER if parent page is GRANT_PUBLIC', async() => {
          // path
          const path1 = '/mup27_pub';
          const path2 = '/mup27_pub/mup28_owner';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_PUBLIC }); // out of update scope
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({
            path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser1], parent: _page1._id,
          }); // update target
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          const newGrantedGroups = [
            { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
            { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
          ];

          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: newGrantedGroups,
          };
          const updatedPage = await updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser1, options); // from GRANT_OWNER to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelA)

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage._id).toStrictEqual(page2._id);

          // grant check
          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
          expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(page2.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);
          expect(page2.grantedUsers.length).toBe(0);
        });
      });
      describe('update grant of a page under a page with GRANT_USER_GROUP', () => {
        test('successfully change to GRANT_USER_GROUP if the group to set is the child or descendant of the parent page group', async() => {
          // path
          const _path1 = '/mup29_A';
          const _path2 = '/mup29_A/mup30_owner';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: _path1, grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantedGroups: { $elemMatch: { item: userGroupIdPModelA } } }); // out of update scope
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ // update target
            path: _path2, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser1], parent: _page1._id,
          });
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          // First round
          // Group relation(parent -> child): userGroupIdPModelA -> userGroupIdPModelB -> userGroupIdPModelC
          const newGrantedGroups = [
            { item: userGroupIdPModelB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
            { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
          ];
          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: newGrantedGroups,
          };
          const updatedPage = await updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser3, options); // from GRANT_OWNER to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelB)

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage).toBeTruthy();
          expect(updatedPage._id).toStrictEqual(page2._id);

          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
          expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(page2.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);
          expect(page2.grantedUsers.length).toBe(0);

          // Second round
          // Update group to groupC which is a grandchild from pageA's point of view
          const secondRoundNewGrantedGroups = [
            { item: userGroupIdPModelC, type: GroupType.userGroup },
            { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelC, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
          ];
          const secondRoundOptions = { grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantUserGroupIds: secondRoundNewGrantedGroups }; // from GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelB) to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelC)
          // undo grantedGroups populate to prevent Page.hydrate error
          _page2.grantedGroups.forEach((group) => {
            group.item = group.item._id;
          });
          const secondRoundUpdatedPage = await updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'new', pModelUser3, secondRoundOptions);

          expect(secondRoundUpdatedPage).toBeTruthy();
          expect(secondRoundUpdatedPage.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
          expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(secondRoundUpdatedPage.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(secondRoundNewGrantedGroups);
        });
        test('Fail to change to GRANT_USER_GROUP if the group to set is NOT the child or descendant of the parent page group', async() => {
          // path
          const _path1 = '/mup31_A';
          const _path2 = '/mup31_A/mup32_owner';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: _path1, grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantedGroups: { $elemMatch: { item: userGroupIdPModelA } } });
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ // update target
            path: _path2, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser1._id], parent: _page1._id,
          });
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          // group
          const _groupIsolated = await UserGroup.findById(userGroupIdPModelIsolate);
          expect(_groupIsolated).toBeTruthy();
          // group parent check
          expect(_groupIsolated.parent).toBeUndefined(); // should have no parent

          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: [
              { item: userGroupIdPModelIsolate, type: GroupType.userGroup },
              { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelIsolate, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
            ],
          };
          await expect(updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser1, options)) // from GRANT_OWNER to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelIsolate)
            .rejects.toThrow(new Error('The selected grant or grantedGroup is not assignable to this page.'));

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();

          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([pModelUser1._id]); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedGroups.length).toBe(0); // no group should be set
        });
        test('Fail to change to GRANT_USER_GROUP if the group to set is an ancestor of the parent page group', async() => {
          // path
          const _path1 = '/mup33_C';
          const _path2 = '/mup33_C/mup34_owner';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: _path1, grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantedGroups: { $elemMatch: { item: userGroupIdPModelC } } }); // groupC
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ // update target
            path: _path2, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser3], parent: _page1._id,
          });
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          const options = {
            grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
            grantUserGroupIds: [
              { item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup },
              { item: externalUserGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
            ],
          };

          // Group relation(parent -> child): userGroupIdPModelA -> userGroupIdPModelB -> userGroupIdPModelC
          // this should fail because the groupC is a descendant of groupA
          await expect(updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser3, options)) // from GRANT_OWNER to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelA)
            .rejects.toThrow(new Error('The selected grant or grantedGroup is not assignable to this page.'));

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1._id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2._id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2).toBeTruthy();

          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([pModelUser3._id]); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedGroups.length).toBe(0); // no group should be set
        });
      });
      describe('update grant of a page under a page with GRANT_OWNER', () => {
        test('Fail to change from GRNAT_OWNER', async() => {
          // path
          const path1 = '/mup35_owner';
          const path2 = '/mup35_owner/mup36_owner';
          // page
          const _page1 = await Page.findOne({ path: path1, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser1] });
          const _page2 = await Page.findOne({ // update target
            path: path2, grant: Page.GRANT_OWNER, grantedUsers: [pModelUser1], parent: _page1._id,
          });
          expect(_page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(_page2).toBeTruthy();

          const options = { grant: Page.GRANT_USER_GROUP, grantUserGroupIds: [{ item: userGroupIdPModelA, type: GroupType.userGroup }] };
          await expect(updatePage(_page2, 'new', 'old', pModelUser1, options)) // from GRANT_OWNER to GRANT_USER_GROUP(userGroupIdPModelA)
            .rejects.toThrow(new Error('The selected grant or grantedGroup is not assignable to this page.'));

          const page1 = await Page.findById(_page1.id);
          const page2 = await Page.findById(_page2.id);
          expect(page1).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2).toBeTruthy();
          expect(page2.grant).toBe(Page.GRANT_OWNER); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual([pModelUser1._id]); // should be the same before the update
          expect(page2.grantedGroups.length).toBe(0); // no group should be set
        });
      });

    });

  });


  // see: https://dev.growi.org/635a314eac6bcd85cbf359fc about the specification
  describe('updatePage with overwriteScopesOfDescendants true', () => {
    test('(case 1) it should update all granted descendant pages when update grant is GRANT_PUBLIC', async() => {
      const upodPagegAB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/gAB_upod_1' });
      const upodPagegB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/gAB_upod_1/gB_upod_1' });
      const upodPageonlyB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/gAB_upod_1/onlyB_upod_1' });

      expect(upodPagegAB).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegB).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPageonlyB).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagegAB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPageonlyB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC,
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPage = await updatePage(upodPagegAB, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      const upodPagegBUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/gAB_upod_1/gB_upod_1' });
      const upodPageonlyBUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/gAB_upod_1/onlyB_upod_1' });

      // Changed
      const newGrant = PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC;
      expect(updatedPage.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      // Not changed
      expect(upodPagegBUpdated.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegBUpdated.grantedGroups).toStrictEqual(upodPagegB.grantedGroups);
      expect(upodPageonlyBUpdated.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);
      expect(upodPageonlyBUpdated.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(upodPageonlyB.grantedUsers);
    });
    test('(case 2) it should update all granted descendant pages when all descendant pages are granted by the operator', async() => {
      const upodPagePublic = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2' });
      const upodPagegA = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/gA_upod_2' });
      const upodPagegAIsolated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/gAIsolated_upod_2' });
      const upodPageonlyA = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/onlyA_upod_2' });

      expect(upodPagePublic).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegA).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegAIsolated).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPageonlyA).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagePublic.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC);
      expect(upodPagegA.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegAIsolated.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPageonlyA.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER,
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPage = await updatePage(upodPagePublic, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      const upodPagegAUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/gA_upod_2' });
      const upodPagegAIsolatedUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/gAIsolated_upod_2' });
      const upodPageonlyAUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_2/onlyA_upod_2' });

      // Changed
      const newGrant = PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER;
      const newGrantedUsers = [upodUserA._id];
      expect(updatedPage.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(updatedPage.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(newGrantedUsers);
      expect(upodPagegAUpdated.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(upodPagegAUpdated.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(newGrantedUsers);
      expect(upodPagegAIsolatedUpdated.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(upodPagegAIsolatedUpdated.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(newGrantedUsers);
      expect(upodPageonlyAUpdated.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(upodPageonlyAUpdated.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(newGrantedUsers);
    });
    test(`(case 3) it should update all granted descendant pages when update grant is GRANT_USER_GROUP
    , all user groups of descendants are the children or itself of the update user group
    , and all users of descendants belong to the update user group`, async() => {
      const upodPagePublic = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3' });
      const upodPagegAB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/gAB_upod_3' });
      const upodPagegB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/gB_upod_3' });
      const upodPageonlyB = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/onlyB_upod_3' });

      expect(upodPagePublic).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegAB).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegB).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPageonlyB).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagePublic.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC);
      expect(upodPagegAB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPageonlyB.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantUserGroupIds: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPage = await updatePage(upodPagePublic, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      const upodPagegABUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/gAB_upod_3' });
      const upodPagegBUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/gB_upod_3' });
      const upodPageonlyBUpdated = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_3/onlyB_upod_3' });

      // Changed
      const newGrant = PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP;
      const newGrantedGroups = [
        { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
        { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
      ];
      expect(updatedPage.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(updatedPage.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);
      expect(upodPagegABUpdated.grant).toBe(newGrant);
      expect(normalizeGrantedGroups(upodPagegABUpdated.grantedGroups)).toStrictEqual(newGrantedGroups);
      // Not changed
      expect(upodPagegBUpdated.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegBUpdated.grantedGroups).toStrictEqual(upodPagegB.grantedGroups);
      expect(upodPageonlyBUpdated.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);
      expect(upodPageonlyBUpdated.grantedUsers).toStrictEqual(upodPageonlyB.grantedUsers);
    });
    test(`(case 4) it should throw when some of descendants is not granted
    , update grant is GRANT_USER_GROUP
    , and some of user groups of descendants are not children or itself of the update user group`, async() => {
      const upodPagePublic = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_4' });
      const upodPagegA = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_4/gA_upod_4' });
      const upodPagegC = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_4/gC_upod_4' });

      expect(upodPagePublic).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegA).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegC).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagePublic.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC);
      expect(upodPagegA.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPagegC.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantUserGroupIds: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPagePromise = updatePage(upodPagePublic, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      await expect(updatedPagePromise).rejects.toThrowError();
    });
    test(`(case 5) it should throw when some of descendants is not granted
    , update grant is GRANT_USER_GROUP
    , and some of users of descendants does NOT belong to the update user group`, async() => {
      const upodPagePublic = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_5' });
      const upodPagegA = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_5/gA_upod_5' });
      const upodPageonlyC = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_5/onlyC_upod_5' });

      expect(upodPagePublic).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPagegA).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPageonlyC).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagePublic.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC);
      expect(upodPagegA.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP);
      expect(upodPageonlyC.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantUserGroupIds: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPagePromise = updatePage(upodPagePublic, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      await expect(updatedPagePromise).rejects.toThrowError();
    });
    test('(case 6) it should throw when some of descendants is not granted and update grant is GRANT_OWNER', async() => {
      const upodPagePublic = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_6' });
      const upodPageonlyC = await Page.findOne({ path: '/public_upod_6/onlyC_upod_6' });

      expect(upodPagePublic).not.toBeNull();
      expect(upodPageonlyC).not.toBeNull();

      expect(upodPagePublic.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_PUBLIC);
      expect(upodPageonlyC.grant).toBe(PageGrant.GRANT_OWNER);

      // Update
      const options = {
        grant: PageGrant.GRANT_USER_GROUP,
        grantUserGroupIds: [
          { item: upodUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.userGroup },
          { item: upodExternalUserGroupIdAB, type: GroupType.externalUserGroup },
        ],
        overwriteScopesOfDescendants: true,
      };
      const updatedPagePromise = updatePage(upodPagePublic, 'newRevisionBody', 'oldRevisionBody', upodUserA, options);

      await expect(updatedPagePromise).rejects.toThrowError();
    });
  });
});